Jeni's Ice Creams
A scoop of Jeni's ice cream is like a glass of fine wine: You'll want to enjoy it slowly as your taste buds tingle. Jeni's handcrafted ice creams and sorbets range from fresh twists on classic flavors, such as the Honey Vanilla Bean, to delectable feats of culinary fusion, like the spicy, chocolate-y Queen City Cayenne. With a wide range of imaginative flavors benefiting from ripe ingredients, it's no wonder Jeni's is slowly mounting locations all over Columbus; look out for a Dublin shop this spring.
Runners up: Graeter's Ice Cream, Cold Stone Creamery