Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse
This triple-crown winner clearly resonates with readers because it delivers the goods on lots of fronts. Hyde's fine, aged steaks always arrive sear-crusted and juicy inside, because policy here dictates that prime pieces of beef should be cooked at 1,800 degrees - you certainly can't do that at home! But why would you, especially when you consider that Hyde's hospitality-minded staff is there to pamper you in a suave and swanky setting that's sure to impress a first date?
Runners-up: G. Michael's, Bon Vie