Weiland's Gourmet Market
3600 Indianola Ave., Clintonville
This little gem of a local market is tucked into an unassuming Clintonville strip center (between a thrift store and a nail salon). But you can assume plenty. Weiland's peddles gourmet food up front, including house-smoked barbecue and a top-notch butcher counter, and gourmet liquor in the back. The bright and airy booze room boasts a huge selection of cold (!) beer, a full lineup of distilled spirits, and one of the city's best-stocked Scotch cabinets.
Runners-up: Europia, The Hills Market