989 N. High St., Short North
Plentiful and well-edited goodies? Check. Consistently updated stock? Yep. Reasonable prices? Natch. Specializing in clothing, furniture, accessories, art and more from the '30s to the '70s, the bi-level shop requires a minimum of two hours to absorb the multi-roomed awesomeness. Whether you're looking for that elusive quadraphonic '70s stereo system, a multi-tiered Barbie pendant lamp or that missing 1965 issue of Playboy (for your dad, of course), this is your place.
Runners-up: Mad 4 Mod, Boomerang Room