Duh. Not only does Jeni's make the best ice cream ever in Columbus, but this groundbreaking company - which has become a Time magazine-featured national sensation - is in the same major league as the top frozen treats in the entire country. And with each new and unique store opened and each new and innovative seasonal flavor released (made with an emphasis on local ingredients) the Jeni's legend continues to grow.
So if you only know about Jeni's sensational Salty Caramel, then it's time you branch out into head-spinning flavors like a provocative Olive Oil with Sea Salted Pepitas or an aromatic, bright and refreshing Lime Cardamom Yogurt.
Runners-up: Graeter's, Johnson's Real Ice Cream