Last year marked the second Age of Aquarius for this troupe. Shadowbox reprised "Back to the Garden," a theatrical tribute to the music and people of Woodstock lore. Our readers aren't the only ones who applauded their efforts: '60s protest rock favorite Country Joe McDonald liked the show so much he joined them as a guest performer.
Another year at the top of our poll means you readers will likely follow this fun group of comedians, rock musicians and actors to the Brewery District when they make the move there this summer.
Runners-up: CATCO, Columbus Children's Theatre