It seems surprising that Whit's has become the go-to local treat when there's "fancier" ice cream up the road. But Whit's has a back-to-basics charm that's sometimes all you want, and that means a whole lot come summertime.

It seems surprising that Whit's has become the go-to local treat when there's "fancier" ice cream up the road. But Whit's has a back-to-basics charm that's sometimes all you want, and that means a whole lot come summertime.

Runners-up: Pattycake Bakery, Resch's Bakery


Full list of Best of Columbus Dining winners >>