There's finally a rivalry brewing in Columbus that doesn't involve the Buckeyes (unless you count the chocolate peanut butter variety). Jeni's took the throne this year, beating out fellow local favorite Graeter's by a mere .2 percent with its innovative, artisan flavors and seasonal offerings. Never let it be said that your vote doesn't matter — at least when it comes to the really important things in life.

Runners-up: Graeter's, Johnson's Real Ice Cream