And the winners are…
Best new restaurant
First place: Watershed Kitchen and Bar
Second: Trillium Kitchen & Patio
Third: Smoked on High
Best seafood
First place: Columbus Fish Market
Second: Mitchell's Ocean Club
Third: The Pearl
Best steakhouse
First place: The Top
Second: Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse
Third: Mitchell's Steakhouse
Best fine dining restaurant
First place: The Guild House
Second: Lindey's
Third: The Refectory
Best hangover breakfast
First place: Starliner Diner
Second: SuperChef's Breakfast & More
Third: Hang Over Easy
Best brunch
First place: Northstar Cafe
Second: Wolf's Ridge Brewing
Third: Lindey's
Best coffeehouse
First place: Fox in the Snow Cafe
Second: Stauf's Coffee Roasters
Third: Kafe Kerouac
Best quick lunch
First place: Dirty Frank's Hot Dog Palace
Second: Hot Chicken Takeover
Third: Piada Italian Street Food
Best cheap eats
First place: Dirty Frank's Hot Dog Palace
Second: Mikey's Late Night Slice
Third: Tommy's Diner
Best traditional pizza
First place: Mikey's Late Night Slice
Second: Donatos Pizza
Third: Hounddog's Pizza
Best gourmet pizza
First place: Natalie's Coal-Fired Pizza
Second: Harvest Pizzeria
Third: Yellow Brick Pizza
Best burger
First place: The Thurman Cafe
Second: Northstar Cafe
Third: Arch City Tavern
Best fries
First place: Five Guys
Second: Hadley's Bar + Kitchen
Third: Brassica
Best barbecue
First place: City Barbeque
Second: Ray Ray's Hog Pit
Third: Iron Grill BBQ and Brew
Best vegetarian
First place: Brassica
Second: The Angry Baker
Third: Little Eater
Best wings
First place: Rooster's
Second: Winking Lizard Tavern
Third: Quaker Steak & Lube
Best sandwiches
First place: Katzinger's Delicatessen
Second: The Brown Bag Deli Restaurant
Third: The Old Mohawk
Best pub grub
First place: Brazenhead
Second: Old Bag of Nails
Third: 101 Beer Kitchen
Best late-night eats
First place: Mikey's Late Night Slice
Second: Buckeye Donuts
Third: Hounddog's Pizza
Best food truck
First place: Ray Ray's Hog Pit
Second: Paddy Wagon
Third: Mikey's Late Night Slice